Take a film conversation beyond a verdict. A specific disagreement about a scene usually opens more possibilities than a disagreement over whether a title deserves a single score.
Three questions to begin
- Which choice would make this film unmistakable even without its title?
- Where does sound, performance or an effect do something dialogue cannot?
- What second film would reveal a different side of the same idea?
Try the questions on Zardoz, May or Robot Jox. Each gives an extravagant premise a different human problem. This is a reading and discussion guide; it does not display member posts.